ESI vs MALDI: How Peptides Are Ionized for Mass Spectrometry

For in vitro laboratory research use only. This article explains peptide chemistry terms. It makes no claims about the effects of any material.

A mass spectrometer can only measure a peptide once it has been turned into a charged ion in the gas phase. For peptides, two ionization methods dominate: electrospray ionization (ESI) and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI). Both are called “soft” because most peptide ions reach the detector intact. This guide explains how each method works, why their spectra look so different, how to read the peaks each one gives, and what neither one can show.

Why a peptide has to be ionized

A mass spectrometer sorts ions by their mass-to-charge ratio, written m/z, not by mass alone. A neutral peptide can’t be steered by electric fields, so it first has to gain or lose a charge. In positive mode, peptides usually pick up one or more protons (H⁺), and each proton adds about 1.007 Da and one unit of charge. Our guide to peptide molecular weight and mass spec explains monoisotopic and average mass and how m/z is calculated.

How ESI works

In electrospray ionization, the peptide arrives in a liquid flow, often straight from an HPLC column. The liquid passes through a fine capillary held at a high voltage, which sprays it into a mist of charged droplets. As the droplets shrink, charged peptide ions are released into the gas phase and drawn into the instrument.

  • Several charge states. ESI often adds more than one proton to the same peptide, giving a series of ions such as [M+H]⁺, [M+2H]²⁺ and [M+3H]³⁺. Larger peptides with more basic sites (the N-terminal amine and Lys, Arg and His side chains) tend to carry more charges. Our guide to the peptide isoelectric point explains which groups carry charge.
  • Coupled to HPLC. Because ESI works on a flowing liquid, it connects directly to an HPLC column. That combination is LC-MS, the method usually behind an identity result. Our guides to LC-MS identity and HPLC vs LC-MS testing explain what that pairing reports.
  • Analyzers. ESI is paired with many analyzer types, including quadrupole, ion trap, time-of-flight and Orbitrap instruments.

How MALDI works

In MALDI, the peptide is not sprayed. It is dried onto a metal target plate together with a large excess of a matrix: a small organic acid that absorbs ultraviolet light strongly. For peptides, common matrix materials include α-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid (CHCA) and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid (DHB). The peptide and matrix form a crystalline spot.

  • Laser pulse. A short UV laser pulse hits the spot. The matrix absorbs the energy and lifts off the plate, carrying peptide molecules with it, and protons pass from the matrix to the peptides. Our guide to peptide UV absorbance covers how molecules absorb UV light.
  • Mostly one charge. MALDI mainly gives singly charged ions, so each peptide usually shows up as one main [M+H]⁺ peak.
  • Time-of-flight. MALDI is most often paired with a time-of-flight (TOF) analyzer, hence “MALDI-TOF”. Ions get the same push and race down a flight tube; lighter ions arrive first. In reflector mode, an ion mirror sharpens the peaks enough to separate the isotope peaks of a typical peptide.
  • Matrix peaks. The matrix itself forms ions and clusters at low m/z, which can crowd the region where very small peptides would appear.

ESI vs MALDI at a glance

ESI MALDI
Sample form Liquid flow, often straight from HPLC Dried spot on a target plate, with a matrix
Typical charges per peptide Often several (1+, 2+, 3+ and up) Mostly 1+
Coupling to HPLC Direct (LC-MS) Usually separate, spot by spot
Common analyzers Quadrupole, ion trap, TOF, Orbitrap Mostly TOF
What one peptide looks like A series of peaks, one per charge state One main [M+H]⁺ peak
Low m/z region Usually clear of matrix peaks Matrix peaks and clusters
Salts and additives Can lower the signal and add adduct peaks Often described as more tolerant, but still adds adducts
Throughput One LC run per sample Many spots on one plate

Salts and counter-ions left over from synthesis can reduce the signal in both methods and add extra peaks. Our guide to peptide counter-ions explains where they come from.

How to read an ESI spectrum

  • Find the charge from the isotope spacing. Isotope peaks of the same ion sit about 1/z apart: about 1 m/z for 1+, 0.5 for 2+, 0.33 for 3+ and 0.25 for 4+. Our guide to cyclic peptides shows how this spacing separates a 2+ dimer from a 1+ monomer at the same m/z.
  • Work back to the neutral mass. For an [M+zH]ᶻ⁺ ion, M = z × (m/z) − z × 1.007. Software that does this across the whole charge series is called deconvolution, and it reports one neutral mass for the peptide.
  • Check the series agrees. Each charge state should point back to the same neutral mass. A peak that doesn’t fit the series may be a different species.
  • Recognize adducts. A sodium adduct, [M+Na]⁺, sits about 22 m/z above [M+H]⁺; a potassium adduct, [M+K]⁺, about 38 m/z above. At higher charge states the gap shrinks by the same factor z.

How to read a MALDI spectrum

  • Look for one main peak per peptide. The [M+H]⁺ peak gives the mass almost directly: subtract about 1.007 Da for the neutral mass.
  • Expect small side peaks. [M+Na]⁺ and [M+K]⁺ adducts, a weak [M+2H]²⁺ ion at about half the m/z, and sometimes a [2M+H]⁺ cluster at about twice the mass.
  • Ignore the matrix region. Peaks at low m/z are often matrix ions rather than peptide.
  • Check the mode. Reflector mode separates isotope peaks for most peptides. Linear mode gives broader peaks, so the reading is closer to an average mass than a monoisotopic one.

A worked example: one peptide, two spectra

Here is an example with made-up numbers, not a real product. Take a made-up peptide with a monoisotopic mass (M) of 2,000.00 Da. Proton 1.007 Da, sodium ion 22.989 Da, potassium ion 38.963 Da.

Ion How it is calculated m/z Isotope spacing Where it is typical
[M+H]⁺ 2,000.00 + 1.007 ≈ 2,001.01 ≈ 1 MALDI main peak; minor in ESI
[M+2H]²⁺ (2,000.00 + 2 × 1.007) ÷ 2 ≈ 1,001.01 ≈ 0.5 ESI
[M+3H]³⁺ (2,000.00 + 3 × 1.007) ÷ 3 ≈ 667.67 ≈ 0.33 ESI
[M+4H]⁴⁺ (2,000.00 + 4 × 1.007) ÷ 4 ≈ 501.01 ≈ 0.25 ESI
[M+Na]⁺ 2,000.00 + 22.989 ≈ 2,022.99 ≈ 1 MALDI side peak
[M+K]⁺ 2,000.00 + 38.963 ≈ 2,038.96 ≈ 1 MALDI side peak
  • In the ESI spectrum, the same peptide appears at about 1,001.01, 667.67 and 501.01. Working back from the 2+ ion (unrounded m/z 1,001.007): 2 × 1,001.007 − 2 × 1.007 = 2,000.00 Da. Each charge state gives the same answer.
  • In the MALDI spectrum, the peptide appears mainly at about 2,001.01, with small sodium and potassium peaks about 22 and 38 m/z higher.
  • Both spectra describe the same neutral mass. They only look different because of how the ions were made.

What neither method shows on its own

  • Not purity. Peak heights depend on how easily each species forms ions, so they don’t measure how much of each one is present. Purity is measured separately, usually by HPLC-UV. Our guide to HPLC purity explains how that figure is calculated.
  • Not same-mass isomers. A peptide and its D-form, or two sequences with the same atoms in a different order, can have exactly the same mass. Our guide to amino acid chirality explains why D-forms share a mass.
  • Not the sequence. A single mass doesn’t spell out the order of residues. Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), with either ion source, gives sequence information. Our guide to peptide sequencing methods explains how.

A mass that doesn’t match can point to a synthesis side product, such as a missing residue or a leftover protecting group. Our guide to peptide impurities lists the common types and their mass shifts.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between ESI and MALDI?

ESI sprays a peptide from a liquid flow and often gives several charge states. MALDI releases a peptide from a dried matrix spot with a laser pulse and gives mostly singly charged ions.

Why does ESI give multiple charge states?

A peptide in the spray can pick up a proton at more than one basic site, so the same peptide appears as 1+, 2+, 3+ and higher ions, each at a different m/z.

What is a MALDI matrix?

A small organic acid, such as CHCA or DHB, dried together with the peptide. It absorbs the laser’s UV light and helps lift and charge the peptide.

When is ESI used instead of MALDI?

ESI is the usual choice when a mass spectrometer is connected directly to an HPLC column (LC-MS). MALDI-TOF is often used to read many separate spots quickly. Which one a lab uses depends on its instruments and the question asked.

How do you get the mass of a peptide from an ESI spectrum?

Find the charge z from the isotope spacing (about 1/z), then calculate M = z × (m/z) − z × 1.007. Each charge state should give the same mass.

Does a certificate of analysis say whether ESI or MALDI was used?

An identity result compares the measured mass with the mass expected for the stated structure. Check which tests a certificate lists.

Peptix certificates

Each Peptix peptide lot with a published certificate has a third-party Certificate of Analysis showing the lot number, HPLC-UV purity and LC-MS identity. Where a certificate reports net content, the measured amount is printed on that certificate. A certificate reports results for the sample tested, so match the lot number on your order to its certificate. To get the certificate for your lot, contact us with the lot number.

For research use only. Not for human or animal use.

logo
Research customers only

Peptix sells research materials only to qualified researchers and research institutions, for in vitro laboratory research. Not for human or animal use. By continuing, you confirm you are a researcher or are buying for a research organization, and that you are of legal age to enter a binding contract.